[By design] Mariah Overlook - trees not solid

6/17/2017 9:13 AM
Title: Mariah Overlook - trees not solid
Reproduction Rate: 100%
Blocker? no
Details: see pic - trees with red arrows are not solid
Steps to Reproduce: none
User Specs:
OS: Windows 10 (10.0.0) 64bit
CPU: Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-6700 CPU @ 3.40GHz (8) System RAM: 32704
GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070 GPU RAM: 8120
SotA.EarlyAccess.LIVE.Win.64.614.Date.05.30.17
Area: Novia_R8_Alpine01_01_Mariah_Overlook
Area Display Name: Mariah Overlook


Location#1: (105.1, 60.5, 117.0) - shown in pic below
Location#2: (49.2, 74.4, 37.5)
Location#3: (46.3, 77.6, 49.2)
Location#4: (-16.2, 78.4, -3.5)
Location#5: (-54.4, 92.3, -23.6)
Location#6: (23.5, 70.0, -175.3)
Location#7: (35.8, 69.8, -176.0)

 

(YAY im not the only one who finds trees you walk through, see through etc)

 

Rinaldi has been reporting non-solid tree stuff for a long time. The Mad Hatter is another one who has been reporting non-solid tree stuff.

 

Submitted 47182

 

Just a head's up - please don't be mad when we don't 'fix' this later because I found out that technically this is by design. Trees that are small or scrawny enough don't get collision. They're more for show and not intended to be something to block your movement. But we do appreciate the report

 

@Lexie Id go with that but a number of the trees ive seen that I could walk through werent small!

 

@liz_the_wiz Yeah, if they are not small trees I'd say those are bugged.

 

okay...I think the small shrubs and small branches on the trees should be "not solid" so the avatar does not get stuck on all the plant life, but i think the tree trunks should be solid even if they are small. But, in the overall scheme of things, this is small potatoes, and i know there are bigger fish to fry

 

Resubmitting for review again based on continued discussion. If we continue to say it is by design, then this will have to be moved to feedback.

Thank you all.

 

Take into account the tree at Area: Soltown (Novia_R1_City_Soltown) Loc: (4.8, 26.4, -5.8).
The tree in Soltown is thinner than all the birch trees reported by @Rinaldi.
And the tree in Soltown is having a collider.
So the birch trees in Mariah Overlook should have colliders as well as they are thicker than the tree in Soltown.

Screenshot #1:

This tree is having a collider by design.

 

Take into account the tree at
Area: Solace Bridge Outskirts (Novia_R1_Forest04_01) Loc: (-118.8, -2.6, -35.2)
The tree in Solace Bridge Outskirts is thinner than all the birch trees reported by @Rinaldi.
And the tree in Solace Bridge Outskirts is having a collider.
So the birch trees in Mariah Overlook should have colliders as well as they are thicker than the tree in Solace Bridge Outskirts.

Screenshot #1:

This tree is having a collider by design.

Screenshot #2: