[Known] A rose by any other name...

1. Title: Lost Roses While Crafting A Stunning Rose Flower Arrangement
   
2. Reproduction Rate: Only when you fail.
   
3. Blocker? No
   
4. Details: I had 50 vases and 50 of each flower and began the slow but happy process to replenish my Rose Flower Arrangement stash. I didn't even consider that I would lose roses during the process and when I looked at the end I had 1 vase and 49 arrangements - and in my chat log I had 1 failure during the process. Are the roses supposed to be consumed on a failure?
   
5. Steps to Reproduce:Try to make rose flower arrangements till you fail (keeping track of starting quantity)
   
6. User Specs: I don't think it's necessary.

 

Seems like it should consume the vase, not the roses, as it is usually just the mats you purchase from NPCs. But I ain't no rose expert. Submitting bug for review: 49154
Thanks!

 

Doh! I was wrong. This is by design. I'm sorry about that.

 

Oh my. This is harsh and does not sit well with me. First the fact that I can fail putting 4 flowers in a vase with the relevant skill @ level 100 is beyond ridiculous Lexie. I know you probably didn't set that up but seriously think about it. 1 vase and 4 flowers - there should be ZERO chance of failure, this is really true of many of the crafting recipes. Losing 4 flowers that take a long time to grow is just utterly ridiculous. I'll stop now before I get too heated up. This is just another sad example of a crafting system that desperately needs to be adjusted or outright redesigned.

@Lexie

 

@Ameresta Trillion @Lexie
It all depends on the process to craft as noted by this informative video: