[Known] Lost Alchemy Recipes

1. Title: Lost Alchemy Recipes
2. Reproduction Rate: 100%
3. Blocker? Partial, don't trust learning new recipes
4. Details: Lost 2 learned Alchemy recipes twice now. Gem socket 2-handed weapon and Gem socket 1-handed weapon. Learned on Tuesday and were lost after logoff. Learned again on Wednesday and lost after logoff.
5. Steps to Reproduce: Log off and recipes are gone. Learn again, they show up in my recipes and when at station. Log off and log in and gone from both recipes and station. Can provide screenshots showing recipes learned at both the recipe book and station (took before log off last night).
6. User Specs: Win 7 64, version 503 and 504

 

@ShadeObscura - Thank you for reporting. Bug is being recorded for review.

Just out of curiosity and for more details... did you learn them from discovery or from buying the recipes?

 

Same here, but also tailoring masterwork.

Picture shows the emptied recipe book, the part on the right the socketed bow as example.

Lost recipes noticed so far:

• Alchemy Socket 1-handed weapon
  
• Alchemy Socket 2-handed weapon
• Alchemy Socket Armour
• Tailoring Masterwork

I can provide all items I masterworked/socketed myself to proove. Cannot say if any of the 'normal' recipes got lost, have not missed any yet.

 

Are you learning via Discovery or from having purchased the recipe? Discovery shouldn't be available for these anymore, I don't believe.

 

I learned them before, in R35 (or earlier). Checked the recipe book after loding into this release.

 

I learned these in or prior to R35 ( I think more than once) by discovery, losing them each time:

• Alchemy Socket 1-handed weapon
• Alchemy Socket 2-handed weapon
• BlackSmith Masterwork

These however, I learned by discovery in or prior to R35 and I still have them:

• Alchemy Socket Chest
• Tailoring Masterwork
• Carpentry Masterwork

 

Bug submitted: 37337

 

I learned these recipes on 11/15/16 from discovery, I used the 1-handed weapon gem socket recipe on 2 items and the 2-handed weapon gem socket recipe on 1 item. And again on 11/16/17 from discovery, I used the 1-handed weapon gem socket on 1 item and the 2-handed weapon gem socket on 1 item.

On login today after update recipes are gone. (Again). (Would have tested more before Release 36 but ran out of time last night when issue noticed).

 

I lost all the wooden binding recipes in the Milling skill tree, even ones that were used to make items while learning Carpentry recipes.

 

Eh.. @Chris I dont know if i do understand you right.
First, the bug is that recipes vanish. That is, especially now as most cannot be discovered as was the hallmark of crafting in SotA up to now. That needs to be fixed firsthand
The bug of losing recipes is independent of this break of discovery.
Second, those that lost recipes need to get them back - to freely quote: 'recipes discovered before this change are not lost, they are grandfathered in'

Please confirm.

 

You can also prove you had masterworked items via your Masterworking Experience, provided you have it turned to train.
I had same issue with Carp MW. My recipe is gone and can't be relearned. )^8 Not sure where to buy it either. I learned through discovery myself, prior to release 36. Possible as early as R34, though I can't confirm that.

I agree. I'm not comfortable having the game in a 'persistant state' while losing items and/or stats/skills.