1. This forum is for bug reporting of current Live Game Server issues ONLY.
    Be sure to follow the format below, it will help us out greatly in responding. If you do not, your report may not be entered into the system.

    Read BEFORE submitting your first bug: Reporting Bugs… QA 101 Document
    • Search for your bug in all likely categories before posting in order to avoid duplicate reports.
    • Be sure to provide details of what the issue is and how to re-produce it, but keep your bug report factual.
    • Only report oneissue per thread, additional issues may be ignored.
    • Do not add, include or modify the thread moderator tags in the title of the thread. (indicators in the [])
    • Reply to an existing thread if you have additional information for the reported bug.
      Do not use this forum for commentary, your post will be deleted and you may be moderated, suspended or banned if the activity continues.
    • There is no need to submit crash logs. Crash data we require is automatically logged.
    NOTE: Important information including your location and system specs are automatically put into your clipboard when using /bug in the game (DO NOT add additional system specs unless requested). When starting your post, just use <CTRL>-V to insert the data and fill in the entries with no data.

    Please include Screenshots if possible. Images can be saved on our SotA Discord Server here

    If the clipboard does not work, use and fill in this Bug Report Template:
    1. Title:
    2. Reproducible?
    3. Blocker?
    4. Details:
    5. Steps to Reproduce:
    6. User Specs: (RAM, CPU, GPU and Operating System only)
    Dismiss Notice

[Verified] "Xavara, the fire pillar" is not dealing fire/magic damage, but raising fire proof skill?

Discussion in 'Combat, Skills & Magic' started by Barugon, Nov 8, 2020.

  1. Barugon

    Barugon Avatar

    Messages:
    14,281
    Likes Received:
    22,392
    Trophy Points:
    153
    Gender:
    Male
    11/08/2020 15:25
    Title: Fire damage is not mitigated with Fire Proof skill.
    Reproduction Rate: 100%
    Blocker? No.
    Details: The Fire Proof skill does not help mitigate fire damage. Below are screenshots showing the skills and log entries showing the damage I received from Xavara. Note that I used offline mode for this so that I could set the skill levels.
    Steps to Reproduce:
    User Specs:
    OS: Linux 5.8 64bit
    CPU: AMD Ryzen 9 3900X 12-Core Processor (12) System RAM: 32115
    GPU: AMD Radeon RX 5700 XT (NAVI10, DRM 3.38.0, 5.8.18-300.fc33.x86_64, LLVM 11.0.0) GPU RAM: 7403
    SotA.Linux.64.1309.Date.11.06.20
    Area: Novia_R3_Hills02_Hilt_Exterior
    Area Display Name: Nightshade Pass
    Loc: (324.3, 57.8, -102.1)
    Debug: Tm92aWFfUjNfSGlsbHMwMl9IaWx0X0V4dGVyaW9yfHwoMzI0LjI2NCwgNTcuNzc1LCAtMTAyLjEwMil8KDAsIC0wLjc2MSwgMCwgMC42NDkpfDI2MC45NDM3fDEwfDYuMTA3NTU=

    Here are the skills for the first test.

    [​IMG]

    And the damage I received from Xavara.

    Code:
    [11/8/2020 3:12:47 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 88 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:12:47 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 36 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:12:51 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 55 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:12:54 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 32 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:12:58 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 192 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:12:58 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 45 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:03 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 92 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:03 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 41 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:07 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 45 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:11 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 33 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:14 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 100 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:14 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 72 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:18 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 45 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:25 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 78 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:25 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 34 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:28 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 224 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:29 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 50 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:37 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 93 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:37 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 48 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:41 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 37 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:13:41 PM] Gamera has been slain by Xavara, the Fire Pillar!
     

    Here are the skills for the second test.

    [​IMG]

    And the damage I received from Xavara.

    Code:
    [11/8/2020 3:16:36 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 79 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:16:36 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 37 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:16:54 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 86 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:16:54 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 61 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:16:58 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 96 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:16:58 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 50 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:01 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 84 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:01 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 106 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:09 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 92 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:13 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 148 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:13 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 82 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:16 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 31 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:21 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 90 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:25 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 150 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:25 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 48 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:28 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 90 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:28 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 83 points of critical damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:32 PM] Xavara, the Fire Pillar attacks Gamera and hits, dealing 84 points of damage.
    [11/8/2020 3:17:32 PM] Gamera has been slain by Xavara, the Fire Pillar!
    
    Disregarding the criticals, I received an average of 56 points of damage per attack in the first test and and average of 71.5 points of damage per attack in the second test.
    Including the criticals, it's 72 and 83.16 respectively.
     
  2. Anpu

    Anpu Bug Hunter

    Messages:
    6,318
    Likes Received:
    7,332
    Trophy Points:
    153
    Location:
    Pacific Northwest
    According to the log they aren’t doing any fire damage, it’s not stating that.

    Did you test and see the attacks from them raises your fireproof skill? But I don’t think it will.
     
  3. Barugon

    Barugon Avatar

    Messages:
    14,281
    Likes Received:
    22,392
    Trophy Points:
    153
    Gender:
    Male
    Just tested this and yes, each attack from Xavara raises my Fire Proof skill.
     
    Anpu likes this.
  4. Echondas

    Echondas Bug Hunter Bug Moderator

    Messages:
    3,426
    Likes Received:
    3,747
    Trophy Points:
    165
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    NY
    Verified against Xavara - it sounds like the bug is that Xavara is not doing magic/fire damage but possibly physical damage that's still increasing the fire proof skill. I tested against regular 'fire elementals' and those seem to be dealing magic damage:
    I updated the thread title to reflect this, for the devs to better troubleshoot the issue/make adjustments

    @Barugon Please re-test your fire proof skill vs. fire elementals, and confirm if this appears to be the case.

    [11/10/2020 11:09:57 AM] Fire Elemental attacks Echondas and hits, dealing 4 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    [11/10/2020 11:10:00 AM] Fire Elemental attacks Echondas and hits, dealing 4 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    [11/10/2020 11:10:04 AM] Fire Elemental attacks Echondas and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    [11/10/2020 11:10:11 AM] Fire Elemental attacks Echondas and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    [11/10/2020 11:10:15 AM] Fire Elemental attacks Echondas and hits, dealing 4 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    [11/10/2020 11:10:34 AM] Fire Elemental attacks Echondas and hits, dealing 1 point of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
     
    Anpu likes this.
  5. Anpu

    Anpu Bug Hunter

    Messages:
    6,318
    Likes Received:
    7,332
    Trophy Points:
    153
    Location:
    Pacific Northwest
    Test of fire proof skill vs. fire elementals at level 88 fireproof:

    Code:
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 7 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of damage past the parry.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 18 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 2 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of damage past the parry.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 2 points of damage past the parry.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 33 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 18 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 2 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 18 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of damage past the parry.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 7 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 19 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 13 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 17 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 15 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 2 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of damage past the parry.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 3 points of damage past the parry.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of damage past the parry.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    
    At level 1 Fireproof:
    Code:
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 2 points of partially resisted damage due to magic resistance.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 21 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 1 point of glancing damage due to armor.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 9 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 28 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 7 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 12 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 33 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 14 points of critical damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 10 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental tried to attack Anpu but Anpu dodges.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 5 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 8 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 6 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 11 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 4 points of damage.
    Fire Elemental attacks Anpu and hits, dealing 12 points of damage.
    
    Fire elemental in Verdantis Mine
    11/15/2020 16:58
    OS: Windows 10 (10.0.0) 64bit
    CPU: Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-1620 0 @ 3.60GHz (8) System RAM: 16303
    GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1080 GPU RAM: 8079
    SotA.QA.Win.64.1097.Date.11.12.20
    Area: Novia_R8_Hills01_VerdantisMines
    Area Display Name: Verdantis Mines
    Loc: (-48.0, -20.8, 141.0)
    Debug: Tm92aWFfUjhfSGlsbHMwMV9WZXJkYW50aXNNaW5lc3x8KC00OC4wMiwgLTIwLjc4OCwgMTQwLjk4Myl8KDAsIC0wLjgyNiwgMCwgMC41NjMpfDEzNy41NTc4fDE2LjM4OTIyfDguNDY1Nzk4
     
    Net and Barugon like this.